Question:
Asalamualykum Shakyh GF Haddad
I’ve come across some of the ‘Ya Muhammad’ articles in the internet. The tashud refutes whatever bad is being said about the phrase. However, some are now saying why is the Ya Muhammad phrase permissible when the Ashari s and Habibi ali Jifri doesn’t permit, saying ‘Allah moved the rock’ cave story.
Can you please bring some light into this issue?
Answer:
Alaykum Salam,
‘Allah moved the rock’ cave story is a hadith of the Prophet (upon him blessings and peace) so it goes without saying that all Ahl al-Sunna including Asharis and Habib Ali Jafri stand by it and none of them says it is impermissible. Check your information.
Hajj Gibril Haddad
